Fake SC/ST Case | How SC/ST Case Misuse Happens & How to Protect Yourself Legally | Advocate Eppakayala Shiva Kumar

on

 





The Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 — popularly known as the SC/ST Act — is one of the strongest protective laws in India. It was enacted to prevent atrocities against marginalized communities and to ensure quick and effective justice for genuine victims.

However, in recent years, several citizens have raised concerns about the misuse of the Act for personal revenge, family quarrels, land disputes, and business rivalry. While genuine victims deserve complete protection, innocent people falsely implicated in a case must also know their legal rights.

This article explains how fake cases are filed, what the Supreme Court has said, and how to legally protect yourself if you or your client is falsely accused.

📌 Understanding the SC/ST Act

The SC/ST Act is a special legislation that provides stronger punishment, immediate FIR registration, and special courts for offenses committed against SC/ST individuals.

Key features include:

  • Non-bailable offenses

  • Immediate registration of FIR

  • Increased punishment

  • Protection to victims and witnesses

Because of these strong powers, misuse in certain situations has been observed.

📌 How Fake SC/ST Cases Are Misused

Fake or motivated SC/ST cases generally arise in situations such as:

1. Property disputes

Land or house disputes often trigger false allegations to gain advantage.

2. Family disputes

In matrimonial matters, allegations under the Act may be added to pressure the other spouse.

3. Business rivalry

Competitors may use the Act to threaten or suppress business owners.

4. Revenge or personal enmity

Village fights, political rivalry, or personal quarrels may escalate into false FIRs.

5. Workplace conflicts

Employees may misuse the Act to intimidate employers or co-workers.

Important: Misuse in some cases does NOT reduce the importance of the Act.
Genuine victims must be protected, but false cases must be handled legally.

📌 Supreme Court’s Stand on Misuse

🔹 Dr. Subhash Kashinath Mahajan vs. State of Maharashtra (2018)

The Supreme Court observed that:

  • Some complaints are filed to settle personal scores.

  • Immediate arrest is not mandatory.

  • A preliminary inquiry is permissible.

  • Approval of a senior officer is required before arrest.

These guidelines were introduced to prevent harassment of innocent people.

📌 Will You Get Arrested Immediately in a Fake Case?

No.

The police cannot arrest immediately without verifying the complaint.

Courts have clarified:

  • Police must examine whether the complaint makes out a prima facie case.

  • Arrest should be used only when necessary.

  • Accused persons have full right to seek legal remedies.

📌 What To Do If You Are Falsely Accused in an SC/ST Case

Follow these essential steps:

1. Stay Calm — Don’t Run or Hide

Running causes suspicion. Staying available legally protects you.

2. Consult a Criminal Advocate Immediately

An experienced advocate can:

  • Review FIR

  • Identify loopholes

  • Prepare anticipatory bail (AB)

  • Guide you through court remedies

3. Collect Proof of Your Innocence

Gather evidence such as:

  • WhatsApp chats

  • Call recordings

  • Location proof

  • CCTV footage

  • Photos/videos

  • Receipts

  • Witness statements

4. Apply for Anticipatory Bail (AB)

Anticipatory bail is the strongest immediate protection.

You can approach:

  • Sessions Court

  • High Court

Courts generally consider granting bail if:

  • Complaint appears doubtful

  • No caste-based abuse occurred

  • Incident happened elsewhere

  • Delay in complaint filing

  • Rivalry or motive is visible

5. File a Counter Case (If Needed)

If the FIR is proven false, you may file:

  • Giving false information → BNS 217

  • False charge / malicious prosecution / false complaint → BNS 248

  • Defamation (criminal) → BNS 356 / 356(2)

  • Representation to Superintendent of Police

This helps discourage repeated harassment.

📌 When Is It NOT a Valid SC/ST Offence?

Courts have held that the following does not automatically constitute an SC/ST offence:

  • The complainant belongs to SC/ST

  • The accused is non-SC/ST

To attract the Act, the prosecution must prove:

  • There was intentional insult

  • Caste-based abusive words were used

  • It occurred in a public place

  • Targeting was because of their caste

If these elements are missing, the case is weak.

📌 Final Advice

Fake SC/ST cases create fear, stress, and confusion. But the law also provides protections for innocent people.

Remember:

  • Immediate arrest does NOT happen.

  • Courts protect innocent individuals.

  • Proper legal strategy safeguards you completely.

⭐ 📌 Very Important: Approach the High Court for Immediate Protection

Even though the law demands inquiry and verification before arrest, it is always safe and strategic to approach the High Court at the earliest.

High Court can grant:

✔ Anticipatory Bail

✔ Directions to Police not to take coercive steps

✔ Quashing of FIR (in rare cases)

✔ Protection of your fundamental rights

Approaching the High Court early prevents:

  • Harassment

  • Unnecessary police pressure

  • Risk of sudden arrest

  • Misuse of the complaint

Therefore, for maximum safety, ALWAYS consult an advocate and move the High Court quickly for immediate relief.

📌 Conclusion

The SC/ST Act is crucial for protecting genuine victims. But its misuse should not destroy innocent lives. Awareness, evidence, and timely legal action — especially through the High Court — will ensure your protection.

Comments

Post a Comment